Content Moderation Case Studies: Copyright Claims On White Noise (2018)
Furnished content.
Summary: Every platform hosting user generated content these days is pretty much required (usually by law) to have policies in place to deal with copyright-infringing material. However, not all content on these platforms is covered by copyright, and that can potentially lead to complications, since policies are often built off of the assumption that everything must be covered by some form of copyright.
One company involved - Catapult Distribution - say that Tomczak's composition infringes on the copyrights of White Noise Sleep Therapy, a client selling the title Majestic Ocean Waves. It also manages to do the same for the company's Soothing Baby Sleep title. The other complaints come from Merlin Symphonic Distribution and Dig Dis for similar works .It appears that all of the claims were automated claims, using various services that scan videos for similarities. However, it does not appear that any of those services first check if the originating videos actually involve a valid copyright in the first place. Instead, they often are based on an entire account, and just search for any similar videos, whether or not there is a valid copyright.Decisions to be made by YouTube:
In any of the cases where I think a given claim would be an issue, I would dispute it by saying I could either prove that I have made the work, have the original materials that generated the work, or could show enough of the components included in the work to prove originality. This has always been successful for me and I hope it will be in this case as well.Indeed, a few days after he contested the claims (and those claims received widespread press attention), YouTube did release all of the claims on the white noise video. Tomczak has separately argued that this case -- even with the final outcome -- suggests that parts of the system need to change.
"Hopefully cases like these with the white noise, which shows how sort of broken their copyright system is, can shed some light on it or get YouTube to think about changing their system," he said.Originally posted on the Trust & Safety Foundation website.
edit: Policy/auto___content_moderation_case_studies__copyright_claims_on_white_noise__2018_.wikieditish...