The Stunning Inability Of Canada's Heritage Minister To Answer Questions About His Internet Regulation Bill
Furnished content.
We've written about Bill C-10, the Canadian government's attempt to bring online services under the auspices of the country's broadcast regulator, the CRTC, and the way the story about the bill keeps shifting and the promises about what it supposedly won't do keep being broken.Now, work on the the bill has been paused after lawmakers from all four parties voted to ask the Department of Justice for a fresh analysis of its legality under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. They've also asked for the bill's champion, Heritage Minister Steven Guilbeault, and others to come before the committee and discuss its implications. But Guilbeault has consistently demonstrated a total inability to give clear answers (or, sometimes, any answers at all) to questions people raise about their concerns with the bill. This has been made "crystal clear" (a term Guilbeault has wrongly applied to the muddy and vague bill itself) by some of his responses over the past couple of weeks.First, at the end of April, Guilbeault was pressed for details in an interview on the CBC, with host David Common asking why the exclusion for social media content was removed from the bill and how the Minister can still claim it won't be impacted (you can watch the full interview here). As you can see, his answer — inasmuch as it constitutes an answer — is not very convincing:
Steven Guilbeault struggles to justify #BillC10 in disaster interview @davidcommon #cdnpoli pic.twitter.com/e7j9cw6RES— Pundit Class (@punditclass) April 30, 2021
You will not believe what just happened during Question Period in the House of Commons.@S_Guilbeault simply could not have been more crass and despicable trying to defend his indefensible censorship Bill C-10cc @MGeist #cdnpoli pic.twitter.com/1gvPLdGCST— Mr. Surveillance (@surveilz) May 3, 2021
Who will be subject to discoverability regulations under C-10? People with large followings? What's the threshold? @s_guilbeault responds.Read more: https://t.co/m3qjS6rarL #cdnpoli #ctvqp pic.twitter.com/8EFqDMnViu— CTV Question Period (@ctvqp) May 9, 2021
edit: Policy/auto___the_stunning_inability_of_canada_s_heritage_minister_to_answer_questions_about_his_internet_regulation_bill.wikieditish...